Money might not buy happiness, but not having enough of it can have a huge impact on how we feel.
In this episode of 3Spoonies, Karen, Jo and Claire are joined by Anita Pickersgill, who describes herself as a “debt collector with a heart”, to talk about money and mental health. Find out more about her here.
It’s a conversation about debt, the rising cost of simply existing, financial anxiety, disability, running a business when money is tight and the enormous amount of shame we still attach to admitting that we’re struggling financially.
And, importantly, it’s also about what we can actually do when money worries start taking over.
The Connection Between Money and Mental Health
Financial stress rarely stays confined to finances.
When there isn’t enough money to cover everything, you’re not simply looking at numbers on a bank statement. You’re thinking about food, heating, housing, bills, children, pets, transport and all the other things that make up everyday life.
You start asking questions such as:
Can I afford this bill?
What happens if that customer doesn’t pay?
What can I cut back on?
Can I afford to put the heating on?
What happens if something breaks?
Where is the extra money supposed to come from?
When those questions are constantly running through your head, money can begin occupying almost every waking moment.
Anita talks openly during the episode about having come close to breakdown herself because of financial problems. Money worries can affect sleep, concentration and our ability to function, and prolonged stress can eventually affect physical health too.
That creates a particularly cruel cycle: financial stress makes you less able to function or work, but being unable to work can make your financial situation even harder.
When You’ve Already Cut Everything You Can
One of the recurring themes in our conversation is the assumption that someone experiencing financial difficulties simply needs to cut their spending.
But what happens when you’ve already done that?
The cost of food, energy, mortgages, credit and everyday essentials has increased, while the amount of money coming into a household hasn’t necessarily increased alongside it.
There comes a point where there simply isn’t another subscription to cancel or luxury to give up.
And standard calculations about what someone should be able to live on don’t always reflect the reality of individual lives.
Disability and chronic illness can make this particularly complicated. There may be medication, dietary requirements, transport costs, equipment or other expenses that aren’t optional.
Real life doesn’t always fit neatly into a standard household budget.
The Shame Around Money Problems
We are getting better at talking about mental health, although there is still a long way to go.
Talking about money problems can be even harder.
There remains an assumption that if someone is struggling financially, they must have done something wrong.
They spent too much.
They didn’t budget properly.
They should have saved more.
They should have planned for an emergency.
But circumstances change.
Someone can lose their job. A business can lose its biggest customer. A mortgage can increase. A supplier can suddenly put its prices up. Ill health can reduce someone’s ability to work.
One relatively small change can affect everything else and, over several months, develop into a much bigger problem.
This can be particularly difficult in business, where we’re often encouraged to present a permanently successful version of ourselves.
Do Business Owners Have to Pretend Everything Is Fine?
During the episode, Jo shares an occasion when she openly posted that she had bills coming out and didn’t have enough money to pay them.
So she created an offer and told people exactly why.
Some people told her she shouldn’t admit her business was struggling because it looked bad.
But the offer worked.
That leads us into a wider conversation about the pressure to appear successful in business even when the reality behind the scenes is very different.
There is nothing inherently shameful about saying that you need more customers, more work or better cash flow.
Sometimes you don’t need a client eventually.
You need one now.
Being honest about that doesn’t mean your business is a failure.
In fact, as more automated and AI-generated content appears online, Anita believes that showing the real person behind a business is going to become increasingly important.
Debt Can Quickly Become Overwhelming
Credit can be extremely useful.
When the washing machine suddenly breaks and there isn’t enough money available to replace it, being able to spread the cost can solve an immediate problem.
But minimum repayments can also make borrowing appear more affordable than it really is.
A £5 monthly payment becomes £10. Then £15. More borrowing gets added and eventually someone can find themselves paying more towards interest than they are clearing from the original debt.
Anita’s advice is to deal with debt sooner rather than later.
Ignoring letters, emails, calls and messages doesn’t make the debt disappear, but feeling overwhelmed by them can make responding incredibly difficult.
Having someone you trust who can look at the situation without judging you can make a huge difference.
That might be a bookkeeper, broker, financial adviser or another professional who can either help directly or point you towards someone who can.
Knowing Your Numbers Can Reduce Financial Stress
One practical suggestion from Anita is to regularly look at what is actually happening with your money.
That doesn’t necessarily mean obsessively checking your bank balance every day.
Instead, periodically review your finances.
Have you signed up for a free trial that has quietly become a monthly subscription?
Are there continuous card payments you’ve forgotten about?
How much does your household genuinely need each month?
If you’re running a business, what does it actually cost to keep that business running?
Claire explains that she needs to see her incoming and outgoing money visually on a monthly calendar. Without that, she can find herself worrying that there isn’t enough money available even when the money is actually there.
Different systems work for different brains.
The important thing is finding a way of understanding your finances that works for you.
Why Aren’t We Taught This Stuff?
This brings us to another big question from the episode:
Why isn’t practical financial literacy a bigger part of education?
Understanding bills, taxes, credit, mortgages, budgeting and everyday financial management are skills most of us will need throughout our lives.
Yet many people reach adulthood without really understanding them.
Previous generations were also more likely to physically see money being divided between different household expenses.
Anita remembers watching her parents bring home cash and divide it into different amounts for gas, electricity, water and other expenses.
Money is now much less tangible.
Payments happen automatically. Subscriptions disappear from our accounts. Card transactions may take time to appear. Direct debits, standing orders and continuous payment authorities don’t necessarily appear together.
For some people, digital banking makes tracking money much easier.
For others, cash makes far more sense.
Accessibility means recognising that there isn’t one financial management system that works for everybody.
Finding Some Breathing Space
One of the practical forms of support Anita highlights during the conversation is Breathing Space.
The important message from the discussion isn’t simply that support exists. It’s that people often don’t know what help or protections may be available until they’re already struggling.
Financial stress can create so much noise that finding and understanding that information becomes another difficult task.
Learning about your rights before reaching crisis point can therefore be valuable.
And if you are struggling, asking for help sooner rather than later can give you more options.
Money Problems Aren’t a Moral Failing
Perhaps one of the biggest things we can change is how we talk about money.
Financial difficulties don’t automatically mean someone is irresponsible.
Debt doesn’t make someone a bad person.
Needing help isn’t evidence that someone hasn’t tried hard enough.
And admitting that money is tight doesn’t make a business owner unsuccessful.
Money affects almost every area of our lives, so perhaps it shouldn’t be surprising that it can have such a profound effect on our mental health too.
The more we can talk about the reality of financial stress without embarrassment or judgement, the easier it becomes for people to say:
I’m struggling. What can I do next?
And sometimes, being able to have that conversation is where things start to become a little more manageable.
Listen or watch the full episode of 3Spoonies: Money and Mental Health to hear our complete conversation with Anita Pickersgill about financial stress, debt, disability, business, financial literacy and why a little more honesty and empathy around money could make a very big difference.
Find out more about Anita here.